Gun Manufacturing

Mechanical Engineering, the ASME magazine, has an article this month on early firearm manufacturing. It focuses on the difficulties of boring (or drilling) a long straight hole for the gun barrel, a technique still called gundrilling today. Along the way, it mentions that blacksmiths at Colonial Williamsburg can perform the process extremely accurately. We visited there in Spring, 2006, but didn't visit the gunsmiths. We'll have to do that next time!

IE vs. ME

The April, 2007, issue of Industrial Engineer, the monthly magazine of the Institute of Industrial Engineers, has a brief article by Kazuo Takeda in its Ask the Expert feature. The article answers a question about the major differences between industrial engineering (IE) and mechanical engineering (ME). Takeda's answer hits all of the stereotypes of both fields: "the main difference has to do with math versus presentation and communication skills." ME is presented as a math-oriented field ("MEs take math very seriously"), and IE is the more holistic field that requires soft skills ("IEs must be able to understand a problem, identify a process, quantify the options, and present a recommendation.") Moreover, ME is a poor career choice (their focus on a specific area "can limit their careers") while "IEs' are often called into project leadership, supervisory positions, management, and executive roles."

This is really discouraging, and it insults both fields. First by implying that MEs are not well-rounded, which doesn't describe our graduates; second, by implying the IEs aren't as mathematically sophisticated as MEs, which is simply untrue. As one who has a degree in industrial engineering and has taught mechanical engineering for 12 years, I'd like to offer my own answer.

All engineers design things. MEs design mechanical components and systems, based on their knowledge of physical phenomena and using mathematics related to continuous variable dynamic systems. IEs design manufacturing systems, for which I use Hopp and Spearman's broad definition: "an objective-oriented network of processes through which entities flow." This includes everything from factories to banks to hospitals. IEs use mathematics related to discrete event systems. Both have to listen to the customer, define requirements, generate and evaluate solutions, select the best one, verify that it will work, and present their results. The major differences are the types of problems and the type of mathematics and analysis tools used. There are few industries that don't employ both MEs and IEs. Either one can be the start of a successful career in management, if that is what one wants to do.

Richard Warner

Richard Warner (Mike's father) died last week. He taught college in New York and in Memphis, Tennessee, before he and his wife Barbara moved to Paducah, Kentucky. He will be buried tomorrow in Janesville, Wisconsin, where they grew up. Mike has posted a tribute to his dad.

Janesville is a small city in southern Wisconsin. According to its Wikipedia entry and the Janesville Convention and Visitors Bureau, twenty percent of Wisconsin's buildings listed on the National Register of Historic Places can be found in Janesville, which was founded in 1836.

Janesville boasts a huge General Motors assembly plant on the south side of town, overlooking the Rock River. According to a GM press release, on August 23, 2005, the facility produced its 16 millionth vehicle (since 1923). At the time, it made the Chevrolet Suburban and Tahoe, GMC Yukon, Yukon XL, Yukon Denali, Yukon Denali XL and Isuzu/GM Low Cab Forward medium-duty truck.

Mr. and Mrs. Warner have four children (three of them married) and one grandchild. We pray that God will bring the Warner family peace and comfort at this difficult time.

Not Getting into Harvard

My brother Keith sent me a link to a New York Times article titled Young, Gifted, and Not Getting Into Harvard by Michael Winerip. Winerip is a Harvard alumnus who interviews students applying to his alma mater. He realizes that the highly qualified applicants will probably not be accepted. Moreover, he accepts that his own kids will not be going to Harvard. Perhaps he can accept this because he knows (based on his interview experience) that so many excellent students are also not going there.

It good to read an article about how not getting into Harvard (or any other elite school) is not the end of the world. I doubt it will stop the flood of students trying to do so. Elite schools are elite because everyone wants to go there and have that awe-inspiring credential.

My brother and I both have had numerous experiences of mentioning our alma maters (his is California-San Diego and mine is Florida; both of us went to Georgia Tech as undergrads) and not getting the kind of reaction that folks from Cal-Berkeley and Michigan and MIT get. But I suppose that is simply envy. Thanks to our parents and other gifts that God gave us, he and I and my siblings have had opportunities that many others have not. Not getting into Harvard is not the end of the world.

Mystery Writers

Despite my best intentions, it has been too long since my last post.

First is a post by Joseph Bottum over at First Things. The post is about mystery writers but is mostly a tribute to Melville Davisson Post, who wrote the Uncle Abner mystery stories in the early 20th century. (Don't try Wikipedia: there's no entry on him yet.) Along the way, the post mentions numerous fine mystery writers, including Ellery Queen and G.K. Chesterton.

As a kid I read numerous Ellery Queen stories. I had little books of them (about the size of an issue of Readers Digest), and there were more at my grandfather's old cabin (Brookside Cabin) on Shooting Creek in North Carolina. I can still remember the little bookshelf in the cabin living room. Did those make the trip to the "new" cabin?

More recently I've read and listened to G.K. Chesterton's Father Brown stories, which are very good, and I don't read mysteries at all these days.